Butler Photo

Butler,PA Neighborhood Guides

Neighborhoods in Butler, PA – Data, Lifestyle & Local Insights

Neighborhood Map

Exploring the Best Neighborhoods in Butler, PA: A Friendly Guide

Butler, Pennsylvania, offers a charming blend of small-town warmth and vibrant community life, making it an inviting place to live and explore. Whether you're looking at historic districts with tree-lined streets or newer developments with modern amenities, Butler neighborhoods each have their unique vibe. From cozy bungalows near downtown to spacious homes in suburban areas, the diversity of the best neighborhoods in Butler appeals to a wide range of lifestyles and preferences. If you're curious about which areas might suit your needs best, the Butler neighborhoods map is a fantastic tool to get a feel for the layout and offerings in this welcoming city.

Housing, Affordability & Market Conditions

When it comes to housing, Butler boasts a variety of options that fit different budgets. Neighborhoods like Lyndora and West Butler feature affordable single-family homes and charming older properties that attract first-time buyers and families alike. The real estate market here is generally stable, with reasonable prices compared to larger metro areas in Pennsylvania. You’ll find that many homes have spacious yards and mature trees, creating a peaceful atmosphere. For those seeking newer construction, areas on the outskirts of Butler offer modern developments with updated amenities, adding to the appeal of the best neighborhoods in Butler.

Crime, Safety & Neighborhood Stability

Safety is a priority for many when choosing a neighborhood, and Butler does a great job maintaining a sense of security across its communities. Areas like Downtown Butler and the South Butler neighborhoods are considered particularly safe, with active neighborhood watch programs and community engagement supporting stability. While no place is without its challenges, the overall crime rates here are lower than many comparable towns, making Butler neighborhoods a comfortable place to settle down. Local police departments and community organizations work closely to keep these neighborhoods friendly and secure.

Getting Around: Transit Information and Accessibility

Getting around Butler is convenient whether you drive or prefer public transit. The city’s compact size means many neighborhoods are within walking or biking distance to key spots like shops, restaurants, and parks. Butler Transit Authority offers bus services connecting various neighborhoods, making transit accessible for those without cars. Additionally, major highways like PA Route 8 provide easy access to Pittsburgh and other nearby cities, which is a boon for commuters. Neighborhoods closer to downtown tend to have better walkability scores, which is a big plus for residents who prefer a car-light lifestyle.

Food & Social Scene: Are Some Areas More Popular Than Others?

When it comes to food and social life, Butler neighborhoods near the city center shine. The Downtown Butler area is a hub for eateries and nightlife, featuring favorites like the Butler Pantry for hearty American fare and the vibrant Black Dog Tavern for craft beers and live music. Neighborhoods such as South Butler also enjoy proximity to popular cafés, boutique shops, and community events, creating a lively social atmosphere. Residents often gather at local festivals and markets, adding to the sense of community. For a quieter dining experience, suburban neighborhoods offer cozy family-owned restaurants serving up delicious regional dishes.

Things to Do: Popular Attractions and Activities

Butler is rich with attractions that suit all interests. Neighborhoods near the Butler County Community College provide easy access to educational and cultural events. Outdoor enthusiasts appreciate the proximity to Moraine State Park, perfect for hiking, boating, and picnicking just a short drive from many Butler neighborhoods. The Butler Little Theater and the Butler County Historical Society offer entertainment and educational opportunities that attract locals and visitors alike. Whether you enjoy shopping at local boutiques or exploring historic sites, the best neighborhoods in Butler provide plenty to do and discover.

Butler Demographics

Population 13,387
Density (People/sqml.) 4,924
Median Age 38.2
Married Couples
33%
33% of the population of Butler aged 16 years and older are married.
Have Kids
20%
20% of the population aged 16 years or older have children.

Best Neighborhoods

Hood  Med. Age  Have Kids  Home Price  Med. Income  Affordability 
Homeacre-Lyndora 45.8 20.5% $169,674 $72,669 2.4
Meadowood 46.2 18.7% $176,083 $67,336 2.6
Oak Hills 48.6 18.7% $229,600 $88,259 2.7
Meridian 47.9 20.8% $213,157 $81,189 2.7

Butler neighborhoods bring their own blend of lifestyle, affordability, and long-term appeal, and the data in the table above helps highlight what makes each area stand out. By comparing home prices, median income, average age, families with kids, and housing affordability ratios, you can quickly uncover the best neighborhoods in Butler—those that balance cost, character, and overall livability. For budget-minded buyers, the table also makes it easy to identify the most affordable neighborhoods in Butler, where lower home prices combined with local income levels create meaningful value. Families can use the children-per-household data to pinpoint the best neighborhoods for families, revealing which areas offer strong community connections and a family-friendly atmosphere. Meanwhile, adults looking for quieter, age-friendly surroundings can turn to neighborhoods with higher median ages to find the best neighborhoods for retirees, where comfort, stability, and an easy pace of living tend to define the local experience. This data-driven overview offers a clear starting point for understanding how each neighborhood aligns with the lifestyle you want.

Crime in Butler

Violent Crime 40% Higher than Nat. Avg.
Property Crime 8% Lower than Nat. Avg.
Total Crime 0.3% Lower than Nat. Avg.
Crime
 
Reported
 
Butler
/100k
PA
/100k
National
/100k
Murder 1 7.7 5.0 5.0
Rape 0 0.0 27.8 37.5
Robbery 4 30.8 51.4 60.6
Assault 60 462.5 161.4 256.1
Total Violent Crime 65 501 246 359
Burglary 34 262.1 116.7 229.2
Theft 158 1,217.9 1,129.8 1,272.1
Vehicle Theft 17 131.0 188.5 258.8
Total Property Crime 209 1,611 1,435 1,760
TOTAL CRIME 274 2,112 1,681 2,119

Historical Crime Data

Date & Last Updated: This data reflects the 2024 calendar year and was released from the FBI in September, 2025; this is the most current data available.