Smithtown Photo

Smithtown,NY Neighborhood Guides

Neighborhoods in Smithtown, NY – Data, Lifestyle & Local Insights

Neighborhood Map

Discovering the Best Neighborhoods in Smithtown, NY: A Local’s Guide

Smithtown, NY, is a charming town located on Long Island’s North Shore, known for its blend of suburban comfort and scenic beauty. Whether you’re moving here or just exploring, the best neighborhoods in Smithtown offer something for everyone—from quiet, tree-lined streets to bustling commercial hubs. With its proximity to beautiful parks, excellent schools, and family-friendly attractions, Smithtown is a community that balances small-town warmth with access to big-city amenities.

Demographic Insights & Community Composition

The Smithtown neighborhoods map reveals a diverse community with a population that ranges from young families to retirees. Areas like Nesconset and Kings Park are popular among families due to their reputable school districts and safe environments. The town's demographic makeup reflects a strong middle-class presence, with a community that values education, outdoor activities, and local events. Many residents enjoy the tight-knit feel of the town, where neighbors often know one another and community gatherings are common.

Lifestyle Variety: What Different Areas Offer

Each neighborhood in Smithtown has its own unique vibe. For example, the Village of Smithtown boasts quaint boutiques, cozy cafes, and charming restaurants like The Village Taphouse, perfect for a casual night out. Meanwhile, Hauppauge offers a more commercial atmosphere with shopping centers and business parks. Outdoor enthusiasts gravitate towards areas near Caleb Smith State Park, which provides hiking trails and picnic spots. Whether you prefer a lively downtown feel or peaceful suburban streets, Smithtown has lifestyle options to suit your preferences.

Housing, Affordability & Market Conditions

When considering the best neighborhoods in Smithtown, housing options range from historic homes to modern developments. The real estate market here is competitive but offers a variety of price points, making it somewhat affordable compared to other Long Island towns. Neighborhoods like St. James feature charming older homes with character, while areas such as Hauppauge have newer constructions and townhouses. Buyers can find single-family homes, condos, and rental properties, catering to different budgets and needs. Consulting a Smithtown neighborhoods map can help prospective residents identify areas that fit their housing criteria.

The Structure, Culture & Personality of the City’s Neighborhoods

Smithtown’s neighborhoods each bring their own personality to the town’s overall culture. The Village of Smithtown, with its historical landmarks and annual events like the Smithtown Day Festival, exudes a welcoming spirit steeped in tradition. In contrast, the more suburban enclaves like Nesconset blend modern living with an active community lifestyle, including local sports leagues and farmers markets. This blend of old and new, quiet and vibrant, makes Smithtown a dynamic place to call home.

Getting Around: Transit Information and Accessibility

Transportation in Smithtown is convenient for both commuters and locals. The Long Island Rail Road has a station in Smithtown village, providing easy access to New York City and other parts of Long Island. Major highways like the Northern State Parkway and Route 25 run through the town, making car travel straightforward. Local bus services also connect various neighborhoods, though many residents prefer driving due to the suburban layout. The Smithtown neighborhoods map is a handy tool for understanding transit routes and planning your daily commute or weekend excursions.

Things to Do: What are Some Popular Attractions and Things to Do

Smithtown offers plenty of attractions and activities across its neighborhoods. Nature lovers can explore the expansive Caleb Smith State Park Preserve or enjoy the waterfront at Short Beach. Foodies will appreciate dining at local favorites such as The Smithtown Pub or Café 12. Families often visit the Smithtown Historical Society & Museum for a glimpse into the town’s rich past. For shopping and entertainment, the Smith Haven Mall nearby provides plenty of options. Whether you’re seeking outdoor fun, cultural experiences, or a great meal, Smithtown’s neighborhoods have a wealth of opportunities to enjoy.

Smithtown Demographics

Population 25,588
Density (People/sqml.) 2,145
Median Age 46.7
Married Couples
59%
59% of the population of Smithtown aged 16 years and older are married.
Have Kids
30%
30% of the population aged 16 years or older have children.

Best Neighborhoods

Hood  Med. Age  Kids  Home Price  Med. Income  Affordability 
Village of the Branch 44.8 36.7% $599,550 $174,259 3.5

Smithtown neighborhoods bring their own blend of lifestyle, affordability, and long-term appeal, and the data in the table above helps highlight what makes each area stand out. By comparing home prices, median income, average age, families with kids, and housing affordability ratios, you can quickly uncover the best neighborhoods in Smithtown—those that balance cost, character, and overall livability. For budget-minded buyers, the table also makes it easy to identify the most affordable neighborhoods in Smithtown, where lower home prices combined with local income levels create meaningful value. Families can use the children-per-household data to pinpoint the best neighborhoods for families, revealing which areas offer strong community connections and a family-friendly atmosphere. Meanwhile, adults looking for quieter, age-friendly surroundings can turn to neighborhoods with higher median ages to find the best neighborhoods for retirees, where comfort, stability, and an easy pace of living tend to define the local experience. This data-driven overview offers a clear starting point for understanding how each neighborhood aligns with the lifestyle you want.

Crime in Smithtown

Violent Crime 100% Lower than Nat. Avg.
Property Crime 100% Lower than Nat. Avg.
Total Crime 100% Lower than Nat. Avg.
Crime
 
Reported
 
Smithtown
/100k
NY
/100k
National
/100k
Murder     2.7 5.0
Rape     21.7 37.5
Robbery     96.1 60.6
Assault     259.6 256.1
Total Violent Crime     380 359
Burglary     136.6 229.2
Theft     1,432.8 1,272.1
Vehicle Theft     150.2 258.8
Total Property Crime     1,720 1,760
TOTAL CRIME 0 0 2,100 2,119
Date & Last Updated: This data reflects the 2024 calendar year and was released from the FBI in September, 2025; this is the most current data available.