Old Town, Key West,FL

Old Town, Key West, FL, is a charming neighborhood celebrated for its historic ambiance and vibrant cultural scene. Nestled in the northwest part of Key West, this area is perfect for those who appreciate a blend of classic architecture and lively community events. The streets are lined with beautifully preserved conch-style houses, quaint cafes, and eclectic art galleries, making it a delight for anyone who loves exploring local history and unique shops. Living here means you’re always just a short stroll away from iconic spots like the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, where you can dive into the literary history of the island, or the lush Key West Garden Club, ideal for nature lovers looking for some peace and beauty.

For newcomers, Old Town offers a truly walkable lifestyle with plenty of outdoor activities and social opportunities. The neighborhood is known for its welcoming atmosphere and strong sense of community, with frequent events such as art walks, live music at local bars, and seafood festivals that highlight the island’s maritime culture. Whether you enjoy lounging at the famous Smathers Beach or grabbing a bite at one of the many seafood shacks and fine dining restaurants, this neighborhood has something for everyone. Plus, the colorful Duval Street, packed with shops and entertainment venues, is just a quick bike ride away, making it easy to enjoy the lively nightlife without venturing too far from home.

One of the biggest perks of living in Old Town is its close proximity to Downtown Key West, which is only about a 10-minute bike ride or a brief drive. This convenience allows residents to enjoy all the amenities and services of the city center while retreating to the quieter, more historic charm of Old Town when the day winds down. For families and professionals relocating here, the area offers excellent schools, local markets, and a variety of housing options ranging from cozy cottages to spacious historic homes. Overall, Old Town stands out as a welcoming, picturesque neighborhood that perfectly captures the laid-back yet vibrant spirit of Key West, making it a wonderful place to call home.

In Old Town, 8% of residents aged 16 and older are married, which is notably higher than the national average. This could point to a more settled, community-driven neighborhood where long-term residents and homeowners are common. It’s the kind of place where stability, and a close-knit atmosphere make it especially appealing to families and couples looking to put down roots.

With only 8% of people over 16 having children, you can expect an easygoing environment that tends to attract residents seeking a quieter lifestyle. The atmosphere here leans more toward adult-oriented living. Without the constant rhythm of school schedules or kid-centered events, the community maintains a slower, more relaxed pace. This makes it especially appealing to singles, couples, and empty nesters who appreciate tranquil streets, and recreation on their own terms.

Old Town demographics offer valuable insights into the character and lifestyle of the neighborhood, helping you understand who lives there and what daily life might feel like. Home to only about 2,257 residents, Old Town is notably smaller than many other Key West neighborhoods, creating a more peaceful and community-oriented atmosphere. Its lower population can translate to quieter streets, a more relaxed pace of life, and easier access to local amenities — all without sacrificing the vibrant urban lifestyle the city is known for.

Old Town has a population density of 4,289, which strikes a balanced feel when compared to other Key West neighborhoods. The area offers just the right mix of activity and breathing room, creating a community that’s lively yet comfortable, with easy access to amenities and everyday conveniences.

Home to a population with a higher-than-average age of 52, this area offers a calm and refined atmosphere shaped by experience and tradition. The neighborhood’s more mature demographic fosters a strong sense of community, a relaxed pace of life, and an environment that’s both welcoming and well-established — making it an especially appealing choice for retirees seeking comfort, stability, and connection.

The Old Town crime map offers a clear, data-driven look at how crime is distributed throughout the neighborhood, using block group data to highlight both safer areas and potential hot spots. The color-coded map makes it easy to see where crime is more concentrated and where it occurs less frequently, helping residents and prospective buyers better understand local safety patterns. It’s important to note that darker or red zones on the map don’t necessarily mean those areas are unsafe — locations near busy transit hubs, shopping districts, or popular attractions often show higher activity simply due to larger crowds and increased foot traffic.

Housing costs often reflect the desirability and overall character of a neighborhood. In Old Town, home prices come in around $963,888, which is higher than many other areas. This elevated pricing points to a sought-after location with strong demand, well-maintained properties, and access to premium amenities that contribute to a higher quality of life. Historical home price trends and appreciation rates in Old Town can serve as a window into the neighborhood’s economic strength and future potential. By understanding how the market has performed in the past, buyers and investors can better evaluate whether the area offers promising opportunities for growth and long-term value.

With an average rent price of $1,950, rental rates in Old Town are higher than many other neighborhoods. This reflects the area’s desirability and strong demand, often accompanied by well-maintained properties, premium amenities, and a high quality of life.

School ratings in Old Town combine factors like student performance, graduation rates, and standardized test scores to provide a clear picture of overall educational quality. The use of NAEP (National Assessment of Educational Progress) scores adds valuable context by offering a consistent national benchmark to see how local schools compare on a broader scale. Additionally, understanding the overall education level achieved by residents in Old Town can give insight into the community’s priorities and opportunities, helping families make more informed decisions about where to live and how well local schools may support long-term student success.