Stonington Photo

Mystic, Stonington,CT

Neighborhood Data
Proximitii Score score
? /100
Amenities Score Amenities Score Locked
Transit Score Transit & Commute Score Locked
Schools Score Schools Score Locked
Health & Safety Score Health & Safety Score Locked
City Crime Score Crime (City) Score Locked
Location Crime Score Crime (Location) Score Locked
Economy Score Economy Score Locked
Housing Score Housing Score Locked

For those considering a move to the southeast part of Stonington, Mystic offers a charming blend of historic appeal and vibrant local culture. This neighborhood is famous for its maritime heritage, with the Mystic Seaport Museum serving as a standout attraction. Visitors and residents alike enjoy exploring the living history museum that features a recreated 19th-century seafaring village, historic ships, and engaging exhibits. Mystic Aquarium is another highlight, especially popular among families, showcasing marine life from the region and offering interactive experiences. The area’s quaint downtown district is filled with boutique shops, cozy cafes, and delicious seafood restaurants, making it an inviting place to settle in and enjoy a friendly community atmosphere.

Living in Mystic means you’re never far from the water, with scenic views of the Mystic River and easy access to boating and fishing activities. The neighborhood also boasts beautiful parks and walking trails, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts. For those who appreciate arts and culture, the local galleries and theaters add a creative flair to the community. Mystic’s charm is further enhanced by its festivals and events throughout the year, such as the Mystic Outdoor Art Festival and the annual Wooden Boat Show, which bring neighbors together and attract visitors from all around. This sense of community and lively cultural scene make Mystic a delightful place to call home.

Despite its small-town feel, Mystic is conveniently close to Downtown Stonington, just a short drive northwest, allowing residents quick access to additional dining, shopping, and business opportunities. This proximity makes Mystic an ideal spot for those who want a peaceful, picturesque neighborhood while staying connected to the broader amenities of the city. Whether you’re relocating for work, retirement, or simply a change of scenery, Mystic’s combination of historic charm, natural beauty, and welcoming community spirit provides a wonderful environment to start your next chapter.

Mystic Demographics

Population 4,617
Density (People/sqml.) 556
Median Age 54.3
Married Couples
60%
60% of the population of Mystic aged 16 years and older are married.
Have Kids
15%
15% of the population aged 16 years or older have children.

In Mystic, 15% of residents aged 16 and older are married, which is notably higher than the national average. This could point to a more settled, community-driven neighborhood where long-term residents and homeowners are common. It’s the kind of place where stability, and a close-knit atmosphere make it especially appealing to families and couples looking to put down roots.

With only 15% of people over 16 having children, you can expect an easygoing environment that tends to attract residents seeking a quieter lifestyle. The atmosphere here leans more toward adult-oriented living. Without the constant rhythm of school schedules or kid-centered events, the community maintains a slower, more relaxed pace. This makes it especially appealing to singles, couples, and empty nesters who appreciate tranquil streets, and recreation on their own terms.

Age Breakdown

Mystic neighborhood age breakdown chart

Mystic demographics offer valuable insights into the character and lifestyle of the neighborhood, helping you understand who lives there and what daily life might feel like. Home to only about 4,617 residents, Mystic is notably smaller than many other Stonington neighborhoods, creating a more peaceful and community-oriented atmosphere. Its lower population can translate to quieter streets, a more relaxed pace of life, and easier access to local amenities — all without sacrificing the vibrant urban lifestyle the city is known for.

With a lower than average population density of 556 people per square mile, Mystic offers a more open and spacious environment compared to many other Stonington neighborhoods. This often means quieter streets, less congestion, and a relaxed atmosphere — all while still providing access to the amenities and conveniences of city living.

Home to a population with a higher-than-average age of 54, this area offers a calm and refined atmosphere shaped by experience and tradition. The neighborhood’s more mature demographic fosters a strong sense of community, a relaxed pace of life, and an environment that’s both welcoming and well-established — making it an especially appealing choice for retirees seeking comfort, stability, and connection.

Crime in Mystic

Crime Safety Index Score Locked 1 2 3 4 5

 

Total Crime Incidents
Try for free within 1 mile
Score Locked per 100k people

Types of Crime

Mystic neighborhood crime breakdown chart

Mystic Crime Map

The Mystic crime map uses detailed block group boundaries from address-based crime data to visualize crime patterns across the neighborhood, highlighting both low-crime zones and areas with higher levels of reported crime. This crime heat map helps paint a clearer picture of local safety trends, showing how crime can vary from one part of the community to another. Keep in mind that areas with higher activity on the map don’t always equate to dangerous conditions — locations near entertainment districts, major roads, or tourist destinations often see more reports simply due to the larger number of people passing through.

Housing

? /10
Home Price $410,700
Median Rent $1,509
People/Household 2.2

Home Price Breakdown

Mystic neighborhood home price breakdown chart

Rent vs Own

Rent 17% Own 83%

Year Moved In

Before 2010 64% After 2010 36%

Types of Homes in the Area

Market Trends

Year-over-Year Home Prices YoY data

 

Housing costs often reflect the desirability and overall character of a neighborhood. In Mystic, home prices come in around $410,700, which is higher than many other areas. This elevated pricing points to a sought-after location with strong demand, well-maintained properties, and access to premium amenities that contribute to a higher quality of life. Historical home price trends and appreciation rates in Mystic can serve as a window into the neighborhood’s economic strength and future potential. By understanding how the market has performed in the past, buyers and investors can better evaluate whether the area offers promising opportunities for growth and long-term value.

With an average rent price of $1,509, rental rates in Mystic are higher than many other neighborhoods. This reflects the area’s desirability and strong demand, often accompanied by well-maintained properties, premium amenities, and a high quality of life.

Walkability & Lifestyle

Coffee Shops

Anchor
Coffee Shop
min.
min.
Juicery
Coffee Shop
min.
min.

Entertainment

Performance Stage
Theatre Arts
min.
min.
Mystic Seaport Marine Museum
Theme Park
min.
min.

Food & Drink

Schaefer's Spouter Tavern
Bar
min.
min.
Twisters Ice Cream
Sweets
min.
min.

Groceries

McQuade's Marketplace
Grocery Store
min.
min.
Big Y
Grocery Store
min.
min.

Parks

Mystic Little League Field
Park
min.
min.
Playground
Playground
min.
min.

Shops

Variety Store
Gift Shop
min.
min.
Museum Store
Gift Shop
min.
min.

Getting Around

Transit Stops

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Transit Stations

Mystic
Transit Station
min.
min.
 
 
 
 
 
 

Health & Safety

Medical Facilities

CVS Pharmacy
Pharmacy
min.
min.
 
 
 
 
 
 

Health Care

Family Dentistry
Dentist
min.
min.
Hartford HealthCare
Doctor
min.
min.

Safety

Mystic Fire Department B.F. Hoxie Station
Fire Station
min.
min.
Community Policing Office
Police
min.
min.

Top Rated Schools

Name Category Grades Rating
Pine Point School
89 Barnes Rd, Stonington, CT
High School PK - 9 School Score
Stonington Boe Pre-School
49 North Stonington Rd, Old Mystic, CT
Elementary School PK - PK School Score
Virtual Learning Academy
1300 Flanders Road, Mystic, CT
High School 9 - 12 School Score
Deans Mill School
35 Deans Mill Rd., Stonington, CT
Elementary School KG - 4 School Score
Mystic Middle School
204 Mistuxet Ave., Mystic, CT
Elementary School 5 - 8 School Score
Ella T. Grasso Technical High School
189 Fort Hill Rd., Groton, CT
High School 9 - 12 School Score
Groton Middle School
35 Groton Long Point Road, Groton, CT
Elementary School M - M School Score

Education Level Achieved

School ratings in Mystic combine factors like student performance, graduation rates, and standardized test scores to provide a clear picture of overall educational quality. The use of NAEP (National Assessment of Educational Progress) scores adds valuable context by offering a consistent national benchmark to see how local schools compare on a broader scale. Additionally, understanding the overall education level achieved by residents in Mystic can give insight into the community’s priorities and opportunities, helping families make more informed decisions about where to live and how well local schools may support long-term student success.